Sunday, February 5, 2012

Updated on Friday, March 12th, 2010 at 12:03 am in Basketball.

Season Over; What of Lickliter Era?

Season Over; What of Lickliter Era?

Chances are you have been aware of the madness that took place in the Iowa basketball community on Thursday, March 11th.  It will be a day I never forget, because a) it was my youngest daughter’s 1st birthday, and b) it was the day when perhaps the most amazing wildfire in Hawkeye message board history caught fire.

If we could issue wildfire warnings on message boards, I guess you could say the Hawkeye corner of the world wide web was at a critically dry stage, and any old spark could set it off.

That happened on Thursday morning, and I am not exactly certain where it began.  It might have been on the message boards at HawkeyeReport.com, or the Hawkeyelounge.com, or Hawkeyenation.com or HawkeyeInsider.com.  I honestly haven’t tracked that down, but each of those sites had amazing thread views on the topic of Todd Lickliter and his immediate future as Iowa’s head coach.  One thread at HawkeyeReport had over 22,000 page views as of 8:47pm Thursday night, and close to 400 replies.  A thread at Halo had over 6000 views and close to 400 replies.  HawkeyeInsider had three separate threads with more than 3000 page views, and here at HawkeyeNation, we had one thread with 6400 views, one with 4600, and one with more than 16,000 views all on virtually the same topic.  My guess is the servers for each site are still white hot at this late hour.

I know things were crazy the day Steve Alford left town, they were crazy the day Blake Larsen committed to Iowa (the site I was affiliated with at that time, Superhawkeye.com, had more than 1,000,000 page views on that commitment day, still a single day record for any site I have ever been involved with), but today had a unique feel to it.

The tinder was dry, and the spark turned to flame, thanks to those early morning posts speculating that a change may be in the offing.  When Iowa City radio station KCJJ posted on their facebook page that Todd Lickliter was going to resign as head coach, and would add that they were hearing it was going to be announced as having something to do with his health, it was a free for all.

There was even some speculation on ESPN2 during the game about Lickliter’s future, Gary Dolphin asked Lickliter about it in the post game and Lickliter was asked about it numerous times by the gathered media in the post game. Iowa Athletics Director Gary Barta gave a simple statement afterwards, saying:  “I’m so proud of our young men.  It’s been a tough season, but the future is very bright with this group. With the season ending today, I’ll do what I do at the end of every year.  I’ll evaluate 2010 and make preparations for next season.”

Pat Harty of the Iowa City Press Citizen did a fine job of chronicling the days events in this article.

Here is an interesting quote from Coach Lickliter after the game: “You know my future is that I’m healthy, I have a great family,” Lickliter said. “I love what I do. I’ve done it well. And that’s not in my hands.”

So, the question is being asked tonight and will likely be asked over the weekend, where is the program at right now?  Where are they going with regards to the head coaching position?  Is it another year of the Lickliter era, or is Barta going to make a move?

First, I can’t possibly believe that with all of the smoke that was on the message boards today, plus KCJJ’s ‘report’, that there isn’t something going on.  You don’t have to be Sherlock Holmes to arrive at that conclusion.  Thursday’s events were preceded by weekly questions to players about transfers from the Iowa media, and daily rumors on the message boards.  There has been too much chatter to assume everything was hunky dory.

Given that I believe there is something to the smoke, otherwise I, along with a lot of people will have been taken for one heck of a boat ride, we are left to sort of look into the statements that have been given.

First, Barta’s statement didn’t speak specifically to his head coach.  It talked about how proud he was of the players.  Next, Lickliter’s statement talked about how he is in good health, and that decisions on the future are out of his hands and are up to his boss, Gary Barta.

If there is some sort of negotiating going on behind the scenes, these are the kinds of quotes you would expect to come from people that have not yet reached a decision that is agreeable to all parties.  However, you can’t ignore the possibility that there is nothing going on behind the scenes, and Barta, as he has been saying all season long, isn’t going to make any changes.

I know the wording in that last paragraph makes it sound like ‘guilty until proven innocent.’  It’s just that I cannot possibly imagine the amazing day that Thursday was with regards to speculation being nothing more than tens of thousands of Hawkeye fans chasing their tails.

As far as where I stand, I spoke on this topic for nearly 40 minutes on Wednesday on the radio program I am a part of in Des Moines on 1460 KXNO, called ‘Miller & Deace in the Morning’.  You can listen to the podcast by clicking on this link.

In summary, which is hard to do with a 40 minute long monologue, I am at the point where I can no longer see objective reasons for another season under the current leadership.  I like Todd and I like the members of his staff; however, as my cohost likes to say, the fans are probably not going to get the ‘our coach is a good guy’ discount when it comes to season ticket prices next year.

This was the worst three year run in Iowa basketball history, presided over by Todd Lickliter.  He didn’t make the entire mess, but it has gotten worse, not better, three years removed from the Alford era.  Some may say it had to because what Lickliter took over was a train wreck.  That is debatable, but not wholly without some merit.  However, did it have to get 10-22 bad?  Did it have to see Iowa not scoring more than 23 points in the first half of its last five games away from Carver Hawkeye Arena, and trailing by at least nine at halftime in each of those games?  Did it have to see Iowa lose by 27 points at Wisconsin and 35 points at Minnesota (who will not make the NCAA tournament and had just lost 27 points to Michigan, another team that won’t make the tournament) in the final two games of the regular season, both scores being the largest margin of defeat all time in those series that span more than 100 years?  Did Iowa have to lose so many scholarship players in three years?  Did it have to see its best player transfer out of the program for three years in a row?  Did it have to see attendance sink to all time lows?  Did it have to see the actual attendance in the seats dip to below 6,000 live bodies per game? Did it have to see more Illini students in Carver Hawkeye than Iowa students?

It’s tough for me to say ‘yes, it had to’ to that set of facts..or to any one of those facts in particular.  Notice I said facts; these aren’t emotional opinions, these are facts.

So as we get ready to head to bed on Thursday, or if you are reading this Friday morning after you have gotten out of bed, we are all still wondering what’s next for Iowa basketball?  It would seem like the bridge we came across to get here has been blown up, and it’s awfully tough to imagine it somehow being rebuilt to go back across.

Tags: ,

  • 83Hawk

    There was the “Alford to Missouri” fiasco 4 years ago that seemed like a done deal.

    I remain skeptical and still believe Lick will be Iowa’s coach next season. On the other hand, if Barta was not planning on firing Lick before today maybe he has been “forced” into doing it now. If Lick is still here next year, the whole season is going to be a circus….attendance will drop farther, fan unrest will grow with every loss, and Lick and Barta will be constantly badgered with questions about Lick’s future.

    Whatever happens….things are going to get interesting.

  • rickhawk

    I will just say, compare the first 3 years of the KF era, and the Lick era……they are so many parrallels, and to me, very similar ways of rebuilding going on….patience is a virtue people…don’t let fellow talk show buddies, change your views!!!
    There was no fire, just smoke bombs going off today. It was interesting to see fans chasing their tails today….
    Lick will be back next year, he will finally show us what we’ve been waiting to see, great improvement, and we will see the foundation is finally bulding in the BB program. Maybe I’m the only fan left drinking the Koolaid, but I also hope, I’m the only one who said, I told you so after all of this smoke blows over…..

  • 1977Hawkeye

    The football program improved greatly under Kirk Ferentz in its first three years. The basketball program has gotten notably worse in the first three years under Todd Lickliter. What parallels are there here, except to show that Kirk Ferentz can build a program, while Todd Lickliter can destroy them? The Ferentz/Lickliter comparison can stop now. Anybody who sees the great things coming under Lickliter are not basing this off of logic. Only hope. A fool’s hope.

  • Hooper

    I am now very skeptical about these rumors. I am now of the belief they may have been exaggerations by people who wanted Lick gone. From what I heard tonight, nothing is happening. Of course that does not mean it won’t all change by tomorrow.

  • cody

    i personally think it would be stupid to fire lickliter right now. it has been a TERRIBLE 3 seasons but you have to ask yourself…who are we going to find that’s better? nobody in their right minds would want to take over this job right now. i don’t think lickliter has forgotten how to coach…you just have to be patient. i hate seeing iowa basketball where it’s at right now just like everyone else, but sometimes you have to take a few steps back before you can take steps forward. keep lickliter. he WILL get it turned around. rome wasn’t built in a day. i’m not saying he’s not deserving of being fired right now…i’m just saying who else would want to coach here in the state this program is in right now. i guarentee there is not a better coach out there that would take this job. and especially if iowa is firing coaches after 3 seasons. for some elite programs 3 years is a realistic amount of time but for iowa it’s not. it will be a mistake if lickliter is fired. there will be improvement next season. don’t be stupid.

  • Hawke

    During the first three years of the KF era the team played well, even in defeat. You could tell that thinga were heading in the right direction. I’ve been a Lickliter apologist but I’ve never had the feeling this year that the basketball team was heading in the right direction.I don’t think it’s accurate to comnpare the first 3 years of the KF era with the first 3 years of the TL era.

  • rickhawk

    For those saying you can’t compare KF and Lick’s first 3 years, let’s look at them shall we?
    KF’s record and winning percentage in his first 3 years:
    11-24 .315

    Lick’s
    39-58 .402

    Now, some of you say that you could see the improvement on the field KF’s first 3 years, and while I agree, I will also say, with the players that Lick had vs the ones KF had, he’s done more with them! Also, I saw BIG improvement in the players this year, that were here last year, both physically, due to the S&C coach, and mentally…knowing the system. The problem is, that the Big Ten is up big this year, and we’ve lost players. I think winning, clouds a fan’s realistic view of what’s happened in the past, with KF.

  • JonDMiller

    I think comparing the first three years of the Ferentz era to the first three of the Lickliter era as the reason to bring Lickliter back is akin to standing in the middle of a cornfield in Iowa hoping to get struck by lightning because it happened to someone else once.

    I can cite far more examples, probably 10 to 1, where people who had a three year record such as Todd’s that didn’t work out…there will be little evidence to the contrary, because most of those coaches do not get a year four.

  • JonDMiller

    Rick, the Big Ten is not as good this year as we thought it would be. I don’t know that it’s all that much better than last year.

    Minnsesota beat Iowa by 35 days after losing at Michigan by 27. Neither of those teams is going to the tournament.

  • Iahwkfan

    I am struggling for an answer as to why “the Butler way” is not working at Iowa? That system puts winning/exciting basketball on the floor at Butler. It works at OH St so don’t tell me it won’t work in the Big 10, but why not Iowa? Is it the coach or is it the players on campus? I think it boils down to players and you have to be able to recruit and that more than “X’s and O’s could be the problem and demise of this coaching staff.

    Butler over the years has recruited athletic, tough minded perimeter players who can hit the gaps in the defense to either get to the basket off the dribble or kick the ball to the corners. Ohio St. obviously has athletic kids on campus in Columbus. Both teams play exciting/winning basketball using the “Butler way”. It all boils down to getting kids on campus.

    Stevie Hairball “raped” the program in more ways than one and now someone has the job of returning Iowa Basketball to the “Iowa Way”.

    Go Hawks!

  • iowamike21

    If you want to compare a football coach to Lickliter, I’ll give you a historical hand. His name was Frank Lauterbur. He was hired away from Toledo carrying two straight bowl wins, a No. 14 AP ranking and a 23-game winning streak. Lauterbur took over the Hawkeyes in 1971 and lasted 3 seasons. During that time he took a down program to the basement and beyond, recording 1-10 and 0-11 seasons, the only winless season in Iowa football history. Lauterbur clearly was the football equivalent of Mr. Lickliter. And at the end of that 3rd season in Iowa City, the guy who came in with a 23-game winning streak from a mid-major, limped out of town with a 3-year record at Iowa of 4-28-1. Did he forget how to coach? Was he a nice guy? Did he look good in black and gold?

    People have to understand that most good high school coaches could do the coaching part at Iowa or anywhere else, thus the “Do you think he forgot how to coach” mantra is naive. Neither Lauterbur nor Lickliter knew how to run a major college program. They were poor matches for the jobs they took. And just as folks were wringing their hands wondering how Iowa could ever find a decent coach after Lauterbur, it finally did happen in 1979 with Hayden Fry. And, if you want to compare another Iowa football coach to Lickliter, how about Fry? Hayden took over a program that hadn’t had a winning season in 17 years, but in this THIRD season he won the Big Ten title and took the Hawkeyes to the Rose Bowl. And if you think Lickliter faced a tougher task than Fry did, there is no hope for you.

    So calm down. Being a nice guy is hardly a resume to pull down a million dollars a year to coach major college basketball. So check out this major college assistant, Steve Forbes, a native Iowan on Bruce Pearl’s staff at Tennessee: http://www.utsports.com/sports/m-baskbl/mtt/forbes_steve00.html

    Or maybe go unconventional and check out one of Iowa’s all-time greats, on and off the floor, and a great pro with the Chicago Bulls, BJ Armstrong. The right match is out there, just as it was with Hayden Fry and then Kirk Ferentz. Barta’s job is to make sure he finds it this time.

  • 83Hawk

    Rickhawk….you won’t be the only one to say “I told you so”. I’ve been saying all along these rumors are FALSE.

    Lick is NOT going anywhere. He WILL be our coach next season and…if the team wins 14-15 games….will be here the season after that.

    Last night I was thinking this hullaballoo may have forced Barta into pulling the trigger. This morning I’m thinking just the opposite….these “planted” rumors are going to backfire and Barta is going to stand even more firmly by Lick’s side.

    Get used to it Hawks fans….the Lickliter era is far from over.

  • JonDMiller

    Even though he hired him, I have a hard time believing that Barta would risk his own job security at this point by bringing Lickliter back. Pick the right hill to die on; I don’t think this is it

  • Igothawked

    The comparisons of KF and Lick should stop. The football team got progressively better in 3 years under KF. The basketball team got progressively worse in 3 years under Lick. Lick had some players when he came in, KF was left with a bare cupboard.
    Lick had the three best players leave the program each of the last three years. KF did not.
    Players do not like Lick, I’m sorry but there is something about him they do not like. Davis, Palmer, and Petersen are prime examples of this. Freeman too. They did not want to play for this guy. His playing time patterns are horrible, players do not know their role. It is apparent watching this team for the last month, they have given up on him.
    Lick will depart. This is like a marriage citing irreconsiliable differences in the separation. There has been too much smoke for the ties to be repaired. At this point Lick has to be gone. I can’t believe so many people think he will be back.

  • 83Hawk

    You reasoning is sound, Jon, but if Barta were thinking about firing Lick he won’t do it now….because it will look like he was forced into it by the fans. An AD cannot give the impression of not being in control and that is exactly what will happen if Lick isn’t retained.

  • JonDMiller

    83,

    The fans are the ones that allow for there even being an athletic department. The fans allow there to even be a Carver Hawkeye (and certainly a renovation project) and a Kinnick Stadium. The fans pay the bills. Gary had a front row seat all year long in Carver Hawkeye to see who wasn’t there any more. I am guessing he has fielded 1000+ emails on Iowa basketball this year, with how disappointed people are. I guarantee you he has had hundreds of conversations along those lines.

    Gary Barta, Sally Mason, pick your administrator over there; their time will come and it will go. The fans were here before they were and they will be here after they were, long after they have traded in their black and gold clothes for the next color of clothing whose name is on the paycheck they draw. Same as it was for Bob Bowlsby…there are some exceptions to this, those folks that were either born and bred Hawks, or those that retire Hawks (like Bump Elliott, Hayden Fry). Regardless of how much I genuinely like Gary, he is a Hawkeye because the job came open, he applied, and he was hired. While the fans didn’t hire him per se, the fans are the lifeblood of any athletic department.

    And while football is the engine that drives the entire athletic department, basketball is a source of pride for Iowa fans…and the fact that something many of us have held near and dear for our lives is at its worst point in not just our lifetimes, but its history, the mood of the fanbase can sour opinions on everyone just as fast as football, even if it doesn’t carry the same financial implications.

    In the game of PR, the failure that has been the Iowa basketball program for the better part of the last decade risks spoiling the entire soup…he cannot let this mess go on any longer. If he chooses to, that is his call. But if he does that, my guess is the fans will begin to raise more questions, and they won’t just be about Todd Lickliter.

    Which is why I cannot possibly see Gary bringing him back another year now with what has transpired publicly, yesterday. There is no bridge to cross, and the goodwill funds are not there to try and rebuild it.

    I believe this is moot, because I believe Gary has been at work with what he will ultimately do, and that is replace Todd.

  • 83Hawk

    I agree that bringing Lick back is an invitation to disaster. The spotlight next season will be on Lick and his job security..not on the games. The media will be relentless.

    While I still believe Barta won’t fire Lick now because of yesterdays rumor and that he will be back next season, I agree the whole situation has gone too far.

    Here is a scenario that I think will work: Barta tells Lick he is gone. He is given a choice: either be fired outright or else Lick announce he is stepping down…not for health reasons…but for the good of the team….that all the controversy that will be present in the next season will make it impossible for the coaches and players to focus on playing.

    Lick gets his full buyout…he is not publicly fired…Barta does not give the impression of caving in to the fans. Win-win all around.

  • hawkfandan

    It’s all about the money folks. So stop kidding yourselves the Hawks are big business and profits are down. Thats just the way it is. Coach Lickliter must go. Its just business.

  • Billso

    Lick is gone and the announcement will come next week. Why do I believe that? The statements by Barta and Lickliter. They are NOT statements either man would make if they knew Lick was coming back next year.

    The most plausible explanation for yesterday’s events is that an athletic dept source leaked Barta’s intention to fire Lick, before a deal had been completed and/or before Iowa was prepared to announce it. The B10 may also have a moratorium on major announcements during the tourney, much like MLB during the World Series.

  • iloveyoularrystation

    Seriously the worst thing that ever happened to Coach Lickliter is Steve Alford being successful at New Mexico. All of a sudden everybody forgets that Lickliter took over a trashed program that lost the fan base before he ever got here. The students stopped coming to games and attendance started down into its death spiral during Alfords administration. When you lose the students, you’ve lost the fanbase. The mistakes Barta has made have nothing to do with Lickliter they have to do with marketing. If Jamie Pollard who say what you want to is a marketing genius, was Iowas AD the last two years we would not be having these conversations. Jamie Pollard got me to buy an Iowa State football package for goodness sakes. 3 games, 100 bucks, including the hawk game. Sold my Colorado ticket and made up for the other two games. I mean the various packages and possibilities ticket wise with Iowa Basketball right now are limitless. Frankly if I was him the students would get in for 5 bucks every game just to get the place packed. When people see on TV empty seats they think its not worth going to, they hear the students and see it packed, people will show up. Nobody had great expectations for this team this year, nobody thought they would play this hard. Yeah they had two games at the end of the season where they got destroyed, a week before that Jon you and everybody else were talking about seeing improvement.

  • Cardhawks

    To iloveyoularrystation,
    First off continue to drink the Kool-aid and whatever else you want to put in it. Secondly, don’t blame Alford for the failures of the Lickliter era. The two regimes are like night and day, you can’t compare the two. I’ll admit the Alford era wasn’ t the greatest, but to blame him for the low attendance the last few years and the pathetic product that is on the floor is idiotic. I attended the U of I during the first four years of the Alford era and I never once felt the way I do now. Carver might not have been sold out every year but we still saw on average between 11,000-12,000 fans for each game. Also some of the games were sold out. I saw Iowa win one big ten tournament title and make the championship game the following year, they also won it again in 2006. I don’t remember that happening at anytime during the Lickliter era. Also to blame Barta for the seats being empty, that to is idiotic. Did you watch any of the games this year? Barta could have tried all the marketing schemes possible this year and they still would not have drawn over 10,000 fans. College students and frankly most fans don’t want to watch a team that runs the same offense as the Hickory Huskers. It’s not fun for anybody, just look at the players the last half of the season, there was no sign of life and they acted like they didn’t want to be there.

    If he is brought back there will be more backlash from alumni like myself and the gap between the football and basketball program will continue to grow.

  • rdwars

    BRUCE PEARL!

  • rdwars

    Iowa needs to hire a big conference coach. No more SW Missouri States and Butlers. Get it done Barta

  • http://www.hawkeyenation.com seepig

    People need to grow up. Bruce Pearl is NOT coming to Iowa he made that clear when we were looking for a coach after Alford departed. Kevin Stallings is NOT coming to Iowa City….I believe there was a ton of chatter when we hired Alford over him. Fact is we have a pretty darn class coming in next year with Brust, Marble, etc. Why get rid of him now (and I have personally penned on forums here that we’d be better off with Lisa Bluder as head Hawk)? If his team doesn’t get 6-10 games better next year and finish 7th or higher in the Big 10 next year THEN I think we can call the Lickliter era an unequivocal FAILURE.

  • http://www.hawkeyenation.com seepig

    Oh forgot to make this point….Want fans to show up at games?

    WIN SOME OF THE TIME. Winning cures many ills.

  • pmchawk

    wow. This is weird to me. in the last week I’ve learned that Dace’s daughter shares a birthday with my Sister and Jon’s daughter shares a birthday with my wife.

More Articles

HawkeyeNationTV