[TChawk]

Originally Posted by tm3308

I didn't see the Richmond finish, but the Morehead block was clean. The defender had position and went straight up. The contact was initiated by the shooter. And if the shooter initiates the contact with a set defender who is straight up, there is no foul. If the defender had left his feet, or leaned in, there would have been a call. But that was a very good no-call.

Except that his right hand wasn't straight up the whole time and he came out on the shooter with his body....his right hand went down on the shooter also which is a foul.

[DuffMan]

Neither was a foul, both players were straight up.

[CAARHawk]

Sounds like a bracket talking OP post here. Don't worry unless you are a total bonehead, this first round loss shouldn't hurt that much.

[storminspank]

Originally Posted by DuffMan

Neither was a foul, both players were straight up.

Correct.

[TomTerrific]

Originally Posted by 1hawkeye1

Absolutely agree. Why do refs swallow whistles at the end of games??

[TomTerrific]

I just finished reading Scorecasting: The Hidden Influences Behind How Sports are Played and Games are Won by Moskowitz and Wertheim. In the first chapter, Whistle Swollowing, the authors suggest that human behavior is sometimes influenced by omission bias or the understanding that omission-the absence of an act-is far less harmful than act of commission-the committing of an act-even if the outcomes are the same or worse. In the case of referees, they learn early on that fans come to see the players and not them. Therefore, many come to understand that the outrage fans direct toward them when they swallow their whistles at the end of a game is less than the outrage fans express if they believe the officials denied the players a chance to decide the game's outcome. I found Scorecasting quite entertaining because of its use of statistics to challenge many of sports most widely accepted truisms. I especially enjoyed the last chapter: Are the Chicago Cubs Cursed?

[coonhawk]

The upsets from yesterday aside. I think most times you could punch a guy in the junk at the last second and it would have a very good chance of being a no call.

[TomTerrific]

I just finished reading Scorecasting: The Hidden Influences Behind How Sports are Played and Games are Won by Moskowitz and Wertheim. In the first chapter, Whistle Swollowing, the authors suggest that human behavior is sometimes influenced by omission bias or the understanding that omission-the absence of an act-is far less harmful than the act of commission-the committing of an act-even if the outcomes are the same or worse. In the case of referees, they learn early on that fans come to see the players and not them. Therefore, many come to understand that the outrage fans direct toward them when they swallow their whistles at the end of a game is far less than the outrage fans express if they believe the officials denied the players a chance to decide the game's outcome. I found Scorecasting to be an entertaining read because of its use of statistics to challenge many of sports most widely accepted truisms. I especially enjoyed the last chapter: Are the Chicago Cubs Cursed?

[DuffMan]

Did you read it twice?

[HawkeyeMike23]

Hey Tom, read any good books lately?

[H8IAST8]

I thought Morehead St. was a good no call.

[tweeterhawk]

Originally Posted by coonhawk

Anyone else think it is BS that refs won't call last second fouls? Both of the upsets today were prime examples. I agree that refs shouldn't decide the games, but in a way they kind of are deciding the game by not making the call.

Dear Mr. Hawk,

The assertion in your post is inaccurate and unfortunate. I can assure you that all NCAA Division 1 basketball officials call fouls equally in the closing seconds just as they do from tip-off.

Respectfully,

Jim Bain

[1hawkeye1]

Originally Posted by DFaceHawkeye

MSU game the refs didn't swallow their whistles. I know it wasn't a foul, but they called the travel with under a second left. Good call and I was surprised they made it.

I too was surprised, you almost never see that called at the end of a game.

[HawkeyeTech]

Originally Posted by TChawk

He fouled him on the arms and on the body....maybe way at the top he got ball but not from there down.

Take a look at the picture in USA Today (paper version) and see who initiated contact. No foul!

[Knight78]

Originally Posted by tweeterhawk

Dear Mr. Hawk,

The assertion in your post is inaccurate and unfortunate. I can assure you that all NCAA Division 1 basketball officials call fouls equally in the closing seconds just as they do from tip-off.

Respectfully,

Jim Bain

Had to laugh at this one because I cried when it happened. Kevin Boyle called for a foul under the basket when he was at half court. Thanks, Jim, for that call! Cost us that game against Purdue game.