Miller: Don't Call Iowa Win Over Penn State An Upset

September 26, 2009

Written by Jon Miller

Back in January, shortly after the 2009 college football season had come to an end, I took a look at where I thought teams would be ranked heading into the 2009 season.

I compiled my own list and had the Iowa Hawkeyes pegged in the high teens.  I then took a look at some early Top 25 polls that various national sportswriters and websites were putting out at the time and one team kept popping up that I just did not agree with:  Penn State, inside the Top 10.

I couldn’t understand how the Nittany Lions could be ranked that high, considering they lost three first team All Big Ten offensive linemen, every receiver of note, two defensive ends that would enter their names into the NFL draft, every starter in the secondary plus their record setting place kicker.

20 through 25, yeah I could see that.  But Top Ten?

At that time, I wrote and said that Penn State would be the most overrated football team in the nation by the time the preseason polls came out in August, but that their soft schedule would keep them in the Top 25 for the entire season.

If that sounds a little bit like an ‘I told you so’, you will have to forgive me.

Some will read this and say, ‘Hey, by calling Penn State an overrated team, you are taking away from Iowa’s win and the type of team they are.’

I can understand that sentiment, but I don’t see it that way.

Penn State is a quality football program, with quality players.  The recruiting rankings would have you believe they have better players on their roster than Iowa does.  In fact, the recruiting rankings would have told you that for nearly every one of the past 10 years or so, and just look at the success Kirk Ferentz has had against Penn State in that time.

However, they don’t have a better football team off paper, this Penn State team is not as talented as this Iowa team and I would have felt that way had Iowa lost a close game to the Nittany Lions.

I have been saying this since Iowa beat Arizona, and I believe it more now than I did one week ago; this is the deepest Iowa football team in the Kirk Ferentz era.  It might also be the fastest team on defense Kirk has had in his days in Iowa City.

Continue reading below

Related In HawkeyeNation Forums

Iowa fans will know this, even if the nation does not, but they played this game without a 1st round NFL left tackle, and its starting tight end that might be the best blocker on the team; Bryan Bulaga and Tony Moeaki.  It’s biggest playmaking receiver, Derrell Johnson-Koulianos, has barely practiced the past two weeks and missed the Arizona game.

Penn State was without star linebacker Sean Lee, and that is a loss for them, but this game was mostly about Iowa’s near total domination when its defense was on the field.

The Nittany Lions came out quick, hitting a 79-yard touchdown play on the first snap of the game for their offense.

After that, the Hawkeyes allowed one field goal and less than 230 yards of offense.  To put it simply, Iowa’s defense dominated Penn State’s offense for much of the game.

Quarterback Darryl Clark is a really nice kid, someone you would love to have on your team.  The same can be said of several of the Penn State players.

Continue reading below

But the Hawkeyes have their number, even in Kinnick East (Beaver Stadium).

Iowa forced four Penn State turnovers, they blocked a punt for a touchdown, forced a safety and nearly got another and took all of the wind out of the ‘Whitehouse’ crowd.

I thought the rainy weather would take the energy out of the crowd, and that might have played a part.  But it was the black and gold swarm, rushing mostly four all night long, that were the bigger party crashers.

So here we are, with the Hawkeyes at 4-0, 2-0 on the road and 1-0 in the Big Ten.

Their first major conference road game is in the rear view mirror.

Continue reading below

I called this one of the five most pivotal games in the Ferentz era earlier this week, because what a win could not only mean to this season, but the type of momentum it could create for this program over the course of the rest of this season and into the next.

The Big Ten is wide open and winnable.  Iowa has the best team on paper and is showing it on the field, yet there are still a few wrinkles to iron out.  The good news, offensively, is that Iowa’s game plan is creating opportunities to move the ball.  They aren’t executing well enough right now to make these games more comfortable for the digestive track.

This team is showing all of the hallmarks of a great Ferentz team…one that keeps building, and building, improving week after week.

This team has room to improve.  It was good to play Penn State as they are on the road to improvement.  They will be a better team in November than they are now, and perhaps by the end of this season they could be worthy of a top 15 ranking.

Two developmental teams met in late September, with one of them flexing their might and imposing their will on the other.

Big Ten, take note;  you better get the Hawkeyes before they get healthy and get going on offense.

With a home game next week against Arkansas State, followed by perhaps another nationally televised home game against Michigan in two weeks, it might be too late.

Trending in Forums View All >

HawkeyeNation Archives View All >

Hawkeye History Podcast: Tangela Smith

Rob Howe

July 16, 2019

Catching up with former Big Ten Player of the Year and new Iowa Hall of Fame inductee.

Kiyron Powell Sees Iowa as Excellent Opportunity

Rob Howe

July 15, 2019

Evansville (IN) power forward plans to visit Hawkeyes.

Bigger Ten: 2019 B1G Predictions

Jon Miller

July 14, 2019

Deace shares his final Big Ten predictions for the 2019 football season in this episode of the Bigger Ten podcast.

HN Podcast: Top 25 & Bowl Predictions

Jon Miller

July 14, 2019

This week’s HN Podcast focuses on Deace’s Top 25 and his final bowl projections.

Schwartz: Ten Sentences – Stats Tell A Story

David Schwartz

July 14, 2019

Nate Stanley has Chuck Long in his sights.

The Complete All-Kirk Ferentz Team

Rob Howe

July 13, 2019

A compilation of all positions after 20 years heading the Hawkeyes for the dean of college coaches.

All-Ferentz Team: Quarterback

Rob Howe

July 13, 2019

Ranking the top signal callers.

All-Ferentz Team: Defensive Back

Rob Howe

July 12, 2019

Sifting through the deep talent pool in the secondary.